Optimization of work and rest modes of flight crew members in order to improve flight safety in civil aviation

Introduction. The researchers carried out the analysis of work and rest modes (WRM) according to the survey data of 667 pilots and the results of investigations of 83 aviation accidents (AA) that occurred in the Russian Federation with heavy aircraft (HA) weighing more than 5,700 kg for the period 2010–2021. We also considered the data of official statistics for the period from 2005 to September 2021. The obtained results indicate the facts of non-compliance with the work and rest modes (WRM), which may be one of the causes of aviation accidents (AA). In this regard, it is relevant to optimize the work and rest modes in order to improve flight safety in civil aviation and organize their stricter control.

The study aims to assess the impact of the actual compliance with the WRM of the crew members of the Civil Aviation Aircraft (CAA) on the occurrence of aviation accidents and to develop proposals for their optimization and control.

Materials and methods. The authors studied a compliance of work and rest modes based on the results of 667 online questionnaires developed on the basis of recommendations of the International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO) on the introduction of a risk management system in airlines related to pilot fatigue, and data from 83 aviation accidents (AA) for the period from 2010 to 2020, presented in the reports of the Interstate Aviation Committee (IAC) on the results of the investigation the causes of their occurrence. When assessing the relevance of the topic, we considered the data of official statistics.

Results. The data of the study indicate that in 18% of cases, one of the main causes of AA was non-compliance with WRM. Among the causes of aviation accidents, the following are important: exceeding the norms of flight time for a month (detected in 10% of cases) and for a year (up to 30%); insufficient preflight rest (46.5% of aircraft commanders and 7.4% of co-pilots); lack of full-fledged vacation for a year (32% of cases). In many cases the Researchers revealed several facts of different violations of work and res modes simultaneously. Data of online questionnaire survey confirm the high prevalence of severe fatigue among pilots: 44% rarely have time to rest between flights, 86% go on a night flight shift without having a full day's sleep. We determined the interrelations between the frequency of fatigue of pilots associated with various types of violations of WRM and the risk of air crashes: the prevalence of fatigue and the frequency of disasters increased with a decrease in the duration of pre-flight rest, an increase in vacation arrears and other factors from 1.2 to 2.1 times.

Conclusion. The results of the study confirm the high significance of WRM disorders in the occurrence of aviation accidents (AA). The researchers compiled a comprehensive program to reduce accidents in air transport associated with violations of WRM and the development of fatigue among crew members. We have provided proposals to amend the current Regulations on WRM.

Ethics. Authors carried out the study in accordance with the International Code of Medical Ethics (1949) and the provisions of the Helsinki Declaration adopted by the World Medical Association (1964). When conducting an online questionnaire survey, before the start of the study, we have introduced all participants with the methodology of its conduct, associated risks and signed an informed voluntary consent.

Contribution:
Zibarev E.V. — the concept and design of the study, writing the text;
Kravchenko O.K. — data collection and processing;
Klimov A.A. — data collection and processing;
Ivashov S.N. — data collection and processing.

Funding. The study had no funding.

Conflict of interests. The authors declare no conflict of interests.

Received: 31.03.2022 / Accepted: 04.04.2022 / Published: 25.04.2022

1. The state of flight safety in civil aviation of the states parties to the agreement on civil aviation and on the use of airspace in 2020. Interstate Aviation Committee. The state of aviation safety in 2020. M.; 2021. 76 p.

2. Zibarev E.V., Bukhtiyarov I.V., Serikov V.V., Kalinina S.A., Merkulova A.G. Assessment of sensory loads in civil aviation pilots. Meditsina truda i promyshlennaya ekologiya. 2020; (7): 435–442. https://doi.org/10.31089/1026-9428-2020-60-7-435-442

3. Lebedev M.A., Palatov S.Yu., Kovrov G.V. Fatigue and its manifestation. RMZh Medicinskoe obozrenie. 2014; (4): 282–286.

4. Manual for the Supervision of the Use of Fatigue Control Mechanisms (FRMS), Doc 9966. Second Edition 2016 in Russian. ICAO; 2017. Available at: https://www.icao.int/safety/fatiguemanagement/FRMS%20Tools/9966_cons_en.pdf.

5. Titelbach A. Pilot Fatigue Barometer (PDF). European Association of Pilots AISBL. https://www.eurocockpit.be/sites/default/files/eca_barometer_on_pilot_fatigue_12_1107_f.pdf

6. Zibarev E.V., Bukhtiyarov I.V., Valtseva E.A., Tokarev A.V. Assessment of labor intensity indicators and factors affecting fatigue in civil aviation pilots based on the results of the survey. Meditsina truda i promyshlennaya ekologiya. 2021; (6): 356–364.

7. Grzhibovsky A.M. Analysis of nominal data (independent observations). Ekologiya cheloveka. 2008; (6): 58–68.

8. The Regulation on the specifics of the working time and rest time of crew members of civil aviation aircraft of the Russian Federation, approved by the by Order of the Ministry of Transport of the Russian Federation dated 21.11.2005 No. 139 (ed. 17.09.2010).

9. Safety Management Manual (RUBP). International Civil Aviation Organization. ICAO Doc 9859. 2013.

10. Missoni E., Missoni I., Nikolic N. Сivil aviation rules on crew flight time, flight duty, and rest: comparison of 10 ICAO member states. Aviation, Space, and Environmental Medicine. 2009; (2): 135–138.

11. Honn K.A., Satterfield B.C., McCauley P., Caldwell J.L., Van Dongen H.P. Honn K.A. , et al. Fatiguing effect of multiple take-offs and landings in regional airline operations. Accid Anal Prev. 2016; (86): 199–208.

12. Olaganathan R., Holt T.B., Luedtke J., Bowen B.D. Fatigue and Its Management in the Aviation Industry, with Special Reference to Pilots. J. of Aviation Technology and Engineering 10: 1(2021): 45–57. https://www.researchgate.net/ publication/352094293

13. Dembe A.E., Erickson J.B., Delbos R.G., Banks S.M. The impact of overtime and long work hours on occupational injuries and illnesses: new evidence from the United States. Occup Environ Med. 2005; (9): 58–97.

14. Transport in Russia. 2020. Stat.sb. / Rosstat. М.; 2020.

15. Transport of Russia. Information-statistical bulletin. January-December 2020. Ministry of Transport of the Russian Federation. М.; 2021.

16. Transport of Russia. Information-statistical bulletin. January-December 2020». Ministry of Transport of the Russian Federation. М.; 2022.

17. Website of the Interstate Aviation Committee. https://mak-iac.org/rassledovaniya

18. Mayorova Yu.A., Guziy A.G. Pilot fatigue as a psychophysiological risk factor for aviation safety. Psihologiya i psihotekhnika. 2015; 7(82): 707–716. https://doi.org/10.7256/2070-8955.2015.7.15222

19. Artemov A.D., Lysakov N.D., Lysakova E.N. The human factor in the operation of aviation equipment: Monograph. M.; 2018

20. Preparation of flight operations manual — AN/914. ICAO Standard, Doc. 9376. Second edition. Canada, Montreal; 1997.